Wales: Manager contenders to replace Chris Coleman
Last updated on .From the section Wales
How do you replace the most successful manager in the history of Welsh football?
That is exactly the conundrum facing the Football Association of Wales following Chris Coleman's decision to resign as national team head coach.
The prevalent feeling among Welsh supporters is that Wales' loss is most certainly Sunderland's gain, with the 47-year-old announced as the new manager of the Championship strugglers.
It is little wonder Coleman is held in such high esteem, having not only led Wales to a first major tournament appearance in 58 years at Euro 2016, but defying expectation altogether as Wales reached the semi finals.
The desire to see Coleman remain in the post became a national clamour, a far cry from the early days of his tenure when some called for his resignation and the task of replacing his predecessor seemed impossible.
A former team-mate and close friend of the late Gary Speed, Coleman spoke of the "difficult" circumstance of trying to succeed Speed following his death in 2011.
It took some time, but good results and a close bond with his players turned things around.
Had Wales not failed to qualify for the 2018 World Cup after defeat by the Republic of Ireland, Coleman may have stayed, but the FAW must now find a successor.
BBC Sport Wales looks at the key contenders for the post with time on the FAW's side as the national team next play at the China Cup in March 2018.
The favourite
The bookies believe it is his job to lose and have Manchester United legend Ryan Giggs as the odds-on favourite.
His lack of experience would not be a factor, as Wales have turned to rookie managers in the past in Mark Hughes and Speed, with Stoke boss Hughes believing Giggs to be the right man.
"I think he would be a candidate and good choice," he told BBC Radio 5 live's Sportsweek. "I know from my own personal experience from getting the Welsh job very early in my career - it was my first job."
However, Giggs is by no means a candidate that would unite the nation, despite being a PR dream for the FAW due to his high profile.
Many Wales supporters felt Giggs picked and chose his Wales games as a player and believe he should have earned more than 64 caps.
Giggs is the man most likely, but he will be a polarising choice.
The rookie
Second favourite with the bookies, a legend as a player and surely a manager in the making, but this job might well come too soon for Craig Bellamy.
While his sharp mind and passion for Welsh football will be admired and appreciated by many connected with Wales, Bellamy is in his infancy as a coach, working in the age-grade set-up at Cardiff City under manager Neil Warnock.
He could be a Wales manager of the future - but his time is probably not now.
The experienced candidate
Many might think the circumstances perfect as the stars potentially align for Tony Pulis to take a job he has admitted would interest him.
The 59-year old has arguably done all he can in club management and has just departed West Bromwich Albion.
He is the outstanding candidate on paper and it is fair to say his credentials would appeal to many Welsh supporters.
However, would Pulis be an attractive candidate to the Wales players? Particularly key men like Gareth Bale and Aaron Ramsey?
Wales' recent success was built on the ideas of young coaches in Speed and Coleman and Pulis would be a big departure from that.
The inside man
Described as "the most influential man in Welsh football", Osian Roberts serves both as the national team assistant manager and as technical director of Dragon Park, the FAW coaching facility that has seen the likes of Roberto Martinez, David Ginola and Marcel Desailly earn their coaching qualifications.
In terms of seamless transition, Roberts stepping up to the main role would certainly be an attractive proposition to the Wales players, who enjoy working with him. No-one knows the set-up better.
However, Roberts surely could not combine his technical director role with being national team boss and would he want to give up his position considering he has no experience as a club manager?
Another clue he may not expect to be a candidate for the post is the fact he has already commented about the possibility of Giggs getting the job.
The long shot
Considered an outside chance with the bookmakers, do not count former Wales midfielder Carl Robinson out of the running.
Robinson won 52 caps for Wales between 1999 and 2009 and is a popular figure among the fans for the fact he was always available for his country.
Robinson has quietly built up an impressive managerial CV since leaving the UK in 2007.
He has been head coach of the Vancouver Whitecaps since 2013 and despite modest budgets and expectations, has led them to three MLS play-off appearances.
He will not dominate headlines, but Robinson would be an attractive candidate to many.
The outsider
It might seem crazy, but Thierry Henry is certainly an intriguing potential contender when discussing a successor to Coleman.
As much of a global icon in the game as Giggs, Henry has ties to Wales after doing his coaching qualifications in Newport under Roberts' guidance.
Already working in international football with Martinez as Belgium's assistant, Henry would surely interest the FAW if he wanted the job.
The chance to combine the role with his TV work could be attractive and he has praised the Welsh squad in the past.
If the FAW want a candidate who is as famous as Giggs, but who would not split their fan-base, Henry - despite not being Welsh - would likely be a popular appointment.
Other candidates: Kenny Jackett, Dean Saunders, John Hartson, Robert Page and Slaven Bilic.
Comments
Join the conversation
He's a rookie and needs to go and do his apprenticeship, like gerrard is currently doing
Less of the Man U rubbish BBC
But who's going to take the team talks for friendlies ?
Will he turn up for all the games?
He found it hard as a player!
Cried off with injuries too many times which weren't there for the next Man U game.
Why would his attitude towards representing his country change as a manager?
Coleman's reign began with Wales 48th in Fifa's world rankings and it ends with them in 14th place ? we got further than them over paid passionless lot that lost to iceland? took the best player in the world to knock us out in semis ?
Steve Cooper would be a great shout. A young manager growing his reputation and with a tournament win under his belt should absolutely be considered.
Since when was rogers Welsh ?
Carl Robinson would be ideal. I'd also wouldn't mind a punt on someone like Giggs or Bellamy as long as Osian Roberts is there holding their hand.
And most importantly, is a really passionate Welshman who's been capped more than 50 times.
Good idea to have Bellamy, Giggs or even Henry as an assistant though (I doubt they would take it).
So who?. Plulis, Bilic & Koeman mentioned but all are recent "failures" in some way ..