Cyclone Nisarga: Bombay HC allows cruise ship docked at Mumbai port to move to safe waters

The court allowed the ship to be moved to safer waters on a condition that it returns with crew members on board and asked the three officers including the captain of the ship to surrender their passports with the port authority.

Follow Cyclone Nisarga LIVE Updates

Advocate S Priya for cruise owner Jalesh Cruises Mauritius Ltd. submitted that due to the sheer size of the vessel, it may be impacted by the cyclonic weather and may be damaged, thus posing a threat to other vessels. The owner submitted that vessel is stocked with a requisite bunker to make the onward journey and come back to port.

Advocate Deepak Motiwala for the Mumbai Port Trust supported the application and said that the vessel poses a serious threat to several others in the port and also said that it was not possible to bring the vessel into the berth. “It is extremely risky to bring the vessel into berth because once alongside, the strong currents driven by the weather will in all likelihood damage the berth and property of the port and other vessels,” he submitted.

Advocate Shyam Kapadia for the plaintiff having claims over the ship said that his client would not have any objection if the vessel is temporarily relocated with certain conditions.

The Court accepted the undertaking given by the shipowner that the vessel will be brought back to port after the cyclone passes and that the claims over it are secured.

After hearing submissions, Justice Menon said that given the approaching cyclone, no number of tugs will be able to control the ship at its present location. Justice Menon said, “I am of the view that MV Karnika and its crew must not be imperiled and must be permitted to leave for safe waters, as may be suggested by the Port Trust in consultation with the master of the vessel, so as to avoid the path of the cyclone.”