clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile
A red and yellow triangular slice covered in basil, olive oil, and grated cheese from Mama’s Too.
The house slice at Mama’s Too.
Luke Fortney/Eater NY

The Essential Pizzerias of New York City

New York’s pizza landscape includes Neapolitan, coal-fired, brick oven, Sicilian, and New York-style slices from around the city

View as Map
The house slice at Mama’s Too.
| Luke Fortney/Eater NY

Pizza as we know it showed up in New York City around 1905 at Lombardi’s in Little Italy, though the city had precursors that were closer to focaccia late in the previous century. Lombardi’s was followed by Patsy’s, Totonno’s, and John’s of Bleecker Street, all by baker-disciples of Gennaro Lombardi. From there, the city’s pizzaioli continued to innovate, creating new varieties suited to the tastes and demands of customers.

Today, there’s a never-ending debate on where to find the city’s best pizzas. And while there’s no question that New York City is the nation’s capital of pizza, only a few have ascended to icon status. Here is a collection of pizzerias, spanning all five boroughs, which every pizza-loving New Yorker should visit at least once. For the best neighborhood slice shops, see here.

Read More
Eater maps are curated by editors and aim to reflect a diversity of neighborhoods, cuisines, and prices. Learn more about our editorial process.

Louie & Ernie's Pizza

Copy Link

Head to this venerable pizzeria ensconced in a white frame house in the Schuylerville section of the Bronx for thin-crust pies. It’s a true neighborhood spot, around since 1959, and has snagged headlines for its white and sausage-topped pizzas — two customer favorites. Louie & Ernie’s serves both slices and pies, as well as a long list of wonderful calzones, but little else.

A whole white pie.
The white pizza from Louie & Ernie’s Pizza.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Mama's Too

Copy Link

In an impossibly small space, the luscious square slices are on full display, each of them thicker, greasier, and more lushly topped than the one before. The crusts are crunchy, too, and the tomato sauce is slightly sweet. Note the stylish cupping pepperoni. The poached pear and gorgonzola square is unforgettable, and evidence of Mama’s originality. There’s another location in the West Village.

An overhead photograph of two square slices from Mama’s Too in the West Village.
Square slices with pepperoni and pear from Mama’s Too.
Luke Fortney/Eater NY

Rose & Joe's Italian Bakery

Copy Link

This is a rare Italian bakery that specializes in pizza in a manner similar to the bakeries of Boston’s North End; it also offers Italian cookies and pastries. Head to the back counter for a square slice with a thick blanket of melted mozzarella atop a tangy layer of tomato sauce, and try to arrive just as a pie is coming out of the oven.

A blacked rectangular pie with cheesy slices of pizza, with one in the corner missing.
Rose & Joe’s sheet-type bakery pizza.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Don Antonio

Copy Link

Giorgia Caporuscio has recently taken over ownership of this restaurant from her father, the famous pizziaolo, Roberto Caporuscio. Look for a soft, doughy, and slightly charred pizza best eaten with a knife and fork. One of the lures here in this deep-fried pizza called la montanara, with the toppings applied after frying.

Two pizzas, the one on the right all brown with shreds of meat.
Classic pizza margherita on the left, montanara Genovese on the right, with a beef and pork ragu.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

John's of Bleecker Street

Copy Link

John’s is one of the city’s oldest pizza operations, and it has retained much of its original New York character. Founded in 1929 by John Sasso, an alum of Lombardi’s, the restaurant churns out very thin, coal-oven-fired pizzas judiciously topped with sauce and cheese. Pizzas here are sold strictly by the pie (the awning famously says, “No slices”), with additional toppings like sliced meatballs, onions, ricotta, black olives, crushed garlic, pepperoni, ground sausage, and double mozzarella.

A truck spills coal into a wheel barrow.
An early morning coal delivery at John’s.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Una Pizza Napoletana

Copy Link

Open in one place or another — the Jersey shore, East Village, San Francisco, now the Lower East Side — since 1996, Una Pizza Napoletana produces some of the most perfect evocations of pizzas as they are mde in Naples, the precursors of our own New York style. These are smallish pies, not inexpensive, dappled with char, steaming straight from the oven. Only five or six different configurations are offered on any given day (Thursday, Friday, Saturday only), using scintillating ingredients.

A hand lifting up a small juicy pizza dotted with small red tomatoes.
Filetti pizza sports fresh baby plum tomatoes on its cheesy white expanse.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Lucia Pizza of Soho

Copy Link

Lucia Pizza started as a slice shop in Sheepshead Bay, where it caught the attention of pizza fans and food critics. The second location, in Soho, is just as good. The plain slice costs less than the one at Joe’s Pizza, and it comes with tasty cheese and tart tomato sauce. Try the specialty slices, too: The cream of spinach slice is inspired by the famous steakhouse Peter Luger and the recipe for its vodka slice is a family recipe from owner Salvatore Carlino. There’s a small counter for standing, but most people eat their pizza on paper plates out front.

An overhead photograph of a Grinch green slice of pizza from Lucia Pizza in Soho, Manhattan.
The cream of spinach slice at Lucia Pizza.
Luke Fortney/Eater NY

Scarr's Pizza

Copy Link

Scarr’s Pizza swapped spaces, opening a new spot 35 Orchard Street, across from the original slice shop. Even though the new location is bigger than its humble beginnings at 750-square feet, customers sometimes still form lines. Owner Scarr Pimentel, who grinds his own flour, churns out what has often been described as a standard bearer for the perfect slice.

An overhead photograph of a sunny plain pizza from Scarr’s on the Lower East Side.
The plain pizza at Scarr’s.
Nat Belkov

L'Industrie Pizzeria

Copy Link

Owner Massimo Laveglia describes his Williamsburg pizzeria as a slice spot, but one that embroiders on the traditional concept with some flair. For one thing, the crust is of higher quality, and for another, the toppings — which include ricotta, burrata, spicy salami, and truffle oil — are applied to plain slices as they are ordered. There is a new branch in the West Village.

A hand holds two large slices covered in basil leaves and burrata from L’Industrie in the West Village.
A plain and burrata slice from L’Industrie.
Luke Fortney/Eater NY

La Rose Pizza

Copy Link

One thing that sets New York’s pizza scene apart: You can find just about any style imaginable. La Rose serves thick, Detroit-style slices distinguished by their crisp, cheesy crusts. The pizzas are baked until they’re crunchy on the bottom, but still tender in the middle, then heaped with toppings, like pepperoni, meatballs, anchovies, and vodka sauce. The slices are more expensive — $5 to $8 each — but each one feels like a small meal.

An overhead photograph of a square pizza at La Rose Pizza.
The Opp pizza with jalapenos and basil.
Luke Fortney/Eater NY

Lucali is the kind of cozy sit-down restaurant every neighborhood should have. Mark Iacono’s thin-crust pizzas, made with a three-cheese blend of fresh and imported mozzarella and Grana Padano, plus fresh basil, consistently draw long lines, and it’s impossible to make a reservation. The move is to show up before 5 p.m., add your name to the list, and grab a drink in the neighborhood while you wait. Cash only, BYOB.

A round pie charred in places with whole basil leaves and slices of pepperoni.
A pepperoni pie at Lucali.
Stephanie Tuder/Eater NY

Luigi's Pizza

Copy Link

Luigi’s opened in 1973 in the same well-worn premises near Green-Wood Cemetery. and is now run by Gio Lanzo, whose father-founder Luigi died a few years ago. Pizza has been made there the same way for the last 50 years. Get a grandma-slice broccoli rabe pizza, a white pie, a soppressata slice flecked with green onion, or a regular pizza with fresh mozzarella or vodka sauce.

A glistening slice of pizza with rounds of sausage cut in half.
The epic soppressata slice at Luigi’s.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Denino's Pizzeria

Copy Link

Denino’s is perhaps the most famous pizzeria in Staten Island. Its most exciting pizza, the clam pie, is a molten mass of briny minced clams and mozzarella on a crisp, nicely tanned crust. The dining room is an extension of a barroom that originated in 1937 as a dockworker’s hangout. Denino’s expanded to Greenwich Village in 2016 (followed by the Jersey Shore) and the new place is nearly as good as the original, minus the maritime atmosphere.

A close-up shot of a cheese pie topped with clams.
The vaunted clam pie at Denino’s.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

L&B Spumoni Gardens

Copy Link

This old-school Bensonhurst pizzeria, open since 1939, is a rewarding nice-weather destination with its outdoor setup, yet the indoor dining room (with an extensive menu of Italian American classics) is too often overlooked. Go here for pillowy square pies and the lesser known round ones. Slices are available too, but if you want toppings, you must order a pizza. Leave room for spumoni. This is a good spot for groups.

L and B Spumoni
The sign for L&B Spumoni Gardens
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Lee's Tavern

Copy Link

For diners seeking out a classic bar pie, Lee’s is worth the ferry to Staten Island and ride on the light rail to the Dongan Hills. The low-key corner tavern near the station serves a small, wafer-thin pizza meant to be consumed with a pint of beer, attracting mainly neighborhood locals since it swung its doors open in 1940. Usually topped with a single ingredient in addition to cheese and tomato sauce, the pies are well-priced and come full-sized, too.

The round clam pizza at Lee’s Tavern is topped with cheese and out of the shell clams.
The clam pie at Lee’s Tavern.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Totonno's

Copy Link

Reopened for sit-down following the pandemic, the family-run Totonno’s was recently featured on Netflix’s Somebody Feed Phil, highlighting its near 100-year reign in Coney Island as one of the city’s original coal-oven pizzas. The list of toppings is spare, the premises is small and looks like someone’s living room, but the pies are superb when the oven is cranking at peak temperature, which approaches 900 degrees. (Note that in the off-season it’s only open Saturday and Sunday.)

Three slices of Totonno’s pizza, which has splotches of white mozzarella.
Pizza from Totonno’s.
Bill Addison/Eater

Louie & Ernie's Pizza

Head to this venerable pizzeria ensconced in a white frame house in the Schuylerville section of the Bronx for thin-crust pies. It’s a true neighborhood spot, around since 1959, and has snagged headlines for its white and sausage-topped pizzas — two customer favorites. Louie & Ernie’s serves both slices and pies, as well as a long list of wonderful calzones, but little else.

A whole white pie.
The white pizza from Louie & Ernie’s Pizza.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Mama's Too

In an impossibly small space, the luscious square slices are on full display, each of them thicker, greasier, and more lushly topped than the one before. The crusts are crunchy, too, and the tomato sauce is slightly sweet. Note the stylish cupping pepperoni. The poached pear and gorgonzola square is unforgettable, and evidence of Mama’s originality. There’s another location in the West Village.

An overhead photograph of two square slices from Mama’s Too in the West Village.
Square slices with pepperoni and pear from Mama’s Too.
Luke Fortney/Eater NY

Rose & Joe's Italian Bakery

This is a rare Italian bakery that specializes in pizza in a manner similar to the bakeries of Boston’s North End; it also offers Italian cookies and pastries. Head to the back counter for a square slice with a thick blanket of melted mozzarella atop a tangy layer of tomato sauce, and try to arrive just as a pie is coming out of the oven.

A blacked rectangular pie with cheesy slices of pizza, with one in the corner missing.
Rose & Joe’s sheet-type bakery pizza.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Don Antonio

Giorgia Caporuscio has recently taken over ownership of this restaurant from her father, the famous pizziaolo, Roberto Caporuscio. Look for a soft, doughy, and slightly charred pizza best eaten with a knife and fork. One of the lures here in this deep-fried pizza called la montanara, with the toppings applied after frying.

Two pizzas, the one on the right all brown with shreds of meat.
Classic pizza margherita on the left, montanara Genovese on the right, with a beef and pork ragu.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

John's of Bleecker Street

John’s is one of the city’s oldest pizza operations, and it has retained much of its original New York character. Founded in 1929 by John Sasso, an alum of Lombardi’s, the restaurant churns out very thin, coal-oven-fired pizzas judiciously topped with sauce and cheese. Pizzas here are sold strictly by the pie (the awning famously says, “No slices”), with additional toppings like sliced meatballs, onions, ricotta, black olives, crushed garlic, pepperoni, ground sausage, and double mozzarella.

A truck spills coal into a wheel barrow.
An early morning coal delivery at John’s.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Una Pizza Napoletana

Open in one place or another — the Jersey shore, East Village, San Francisco, now the Lower East Side — since 1996, Una Pizza Napoletana produces some of the most perfect evocations of pizzas as they are mde in Naples, the precursors of our own New York style. These are smallish pies, not inexpensive, dappled with char, steaming straight from the oven. Only five or six different configurations are offered on any given day (Thursday, Friday, Saturday only), using scintillating ingredients.

A hand lifting up a small juicy pizza dotted with small red tomatoes.
Filetti pizza sports fresh baby plum tomatoes on its cheesy white expanse.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Lucia Pizza of Soho

Lucia Pizza started as a slice shop in Sheepshead Bay, where it caught the attention of pizza fans and food critics. The second location, in Soho, is just as good. The plain slice costs less than the one at Joe’s Pizza, and it comes with tasty cheese and tart tomato sauce. Try the specialty slices, too: The cream of spinach slice is inspired by the famous steakhouse Peter Luger and the recipe for its vodka slice is a family recipe from owner Salvatore Carlino. There’s a small counter for standing, but most people eat their pizza on paper plates out front.

An overhead photograph of a Grinch green slice of pizza from Lucia Pizza in Soho, Manhattan.
The cream of spinach slice at Lucia Pizza.
Luke Fortney/Eater NY

Scarr's Pizza

Scarr’s Pizza swapped spaces, opening a new spot 35 Orchard Street, across from the original slice shop. Even though the new location is bigger than its humble beginnings at 750-square feet, customers sometimes still form lines. Owner Scarr Pimentel, who grinds his own flour, churns out what has often been described as a standard bearer for the perfect slice.

An overhead photograph of a sunny plain pizza from Scarr’s on the Lower East Side.
The plain pizza at Scarr’s.
Nat Belkov

L'Industrie Pizzeria

Owner Massimo Laveglia describes his Williamsburg pizzeria as a slice spot, but one that embroiders on the traditional concept with some flair. For one thing, the crust is of higher quality, and for another, the toppings — which include ricotta, burrata, spicy salami, and truffle oil — are applied to plain slices as they are ordered. There is a new branch in the West Village.

A hand holds two large slices covered in basil leaves and burrata from L’Industrie in the West Village.
A plain and burrata slice from L’Industrie.
Luke Fortney/Eater NY

La Rose Pizza

One thing that sets New York’s pizza scene apart: You can find just about any style imaginable. La Rose serves thick, Detroit-style slices distinguished by their crisp, cheesy crusts. The pizzas are baked until they’re crunchy on the bottom, but still tender in the middle, then heaped with toppings, like pepperoni, meatballs, anchovies, and vodka sauce. The slices are more expensive — $5 to $8 each — but each one feels like a small meal.

An overhead photograph of a square pizza at La Rose Pizza.
The Opp pizza with jalapenos and basil.
Luke Fortney/Eater NY

Lucali

Lucali is the kind of cozy sit-down restaurant every neighborhood should have. Mark Iacono’s thin-crust pizzas, made with a three-cheese blend of fresh and imported mozzarella and Grana Padano, plus fresh basil, consistently draw long lines, and it’s impossible to make a reservation. The move is to show up before 5 p.m., add your name to the list, and grab a drink in the neighborhood while you wait. Cash only, BYOB.

A round pie charred in places with whole basil leaves and slices of pepperoni.
A pepperoni pie at Lucali.
Stephanie Tuder/Eater NY

Luigi's Pizza

Luigi’s opened in 1973 in the same well-worn premises near Green-Wood Cemetery. and is now run by Gio Lanzo, whose father-founder Luigi died a few years ago. Pizza has been made there the same way for the last 50 years. Get a grandma-slice broccoli rabe pizza, a white pie, a soppressata slice flecked with green onion, or a regular pizza with fresh mozzarella or vodka sauce.

A glistening slice of pizza with rounds of sausage cut in half.
The epic soppressata slice at Luigi’s.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Denino's Pizzeria

Denino’s is perhaps the most famous pizzeria in Staten Island. Its most exciting pizza, the clam pie, is a molten mass of briny minced clams and mozzarella on a crisp, nicely tanned crust. The dining room is an extension of a barroom that originated in 1937 as a dockworker’s hangout. Denino’s expanded to Greenwich Village in 2016 (followed by the Jersey Shore) and the new place is nearly as good as the original, minus the maritime atmosphere.

A close-up shot of a cheese pie topped with clams.
The vaunted clam pie at Denino’s.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

L&B Spumoni Gardens

This old-school Bensonhurst pizzeria, open since 1939, is a rewarding nice-weather destination with its outdoor setup, yet the indoor dining room (with an extensive menu of Italian American classics) is too often overlooked. Go here for pillowy square pies and the lesser known round ones. Slices are available too, but if you want toppings, you must order a pizza. Leave room for spumoni. This is a good spot for groups.

L and B Spumoni
The sign for L&B Spumoni Gardens
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Lee's Tavern

For diners seeking out a classic bar pie, Lee’s is worth the ferry to Staten Island and ride on the light rail to the Dongan Hills. The low-key corner tavern near the station serves a small, wafer-thin pizza meant to be consumed with a pint of beer, attracting mainly neighborhood locals since it swung its doors open in 1940. Usually topped with a single ingredient in addition to cheese and tomato sauce, the pies are well-priced and come full-sized, too.

The round clam pizza at Lee’s Tavern is topped with cheese and out of the shell clams.
The clam pie at Lee’s Tavern.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Related Maps

Totonno's

Reopened for sit-down following the pandemic, the family-run Totonno’s was recently featured on Netflix’s Somebody Feed Phil, highlighting its near 100-year reign in Coney Island as one of the city’s original coal-oven pizzas. The list of toppings is spare, the premises is small and looks like someone’s living room, but the pies are superb when the oven is cranking at peak temperature, which approaches 900 degrees. (Note that in the off-season it’s only open Saturday and Sunday.)

Three slices of Totonno’s pizza, which has splotches of white mozzarella.
Pizza from Totonno’s.
Bill Addison/Eater

Related Maps