Skip to content

Making it count: Albany must require hand tallies of paper ballots in close elections

Queens is doing it the smart way.
Jesse Ward/for New York Daily News
Queens is doing it the smart way.

As the full hand count of 91,000 paper ballots gets underway in the Queens district attorney Democratic primary, where 16 votes now separate Melinda Katz and Tiffany Cabán, the results of the Watertown mayoral primary 300 miles north remain deadlocked because a county Board of Elections isn’t allowing a hand count of 2,400 cast ballots.

Jefferson County should get its act together and start recounting the votes.

Hand counting is the obvious solution for razor-close contests. It should be written into state law, since scanning machines fail to register votes when voters fail to darken the little ovals, and instead indicate their choices with check marks or circling or underlining.

But the county Board’s Democratic and Republican commissioners are both refusing to examine the ballots, claiming that no court has ever ordered a manual count. Not true. There was a court-approved hand count in 2011 outside Buffalo that flipped the results.

Break the tie. Get out the calculators. Start counting.